Okay, the following content depicts a situation in Germany, but I'll still make it available in English here bI think it might also be interesting to "foreign" anime fans.
Okay, so, in Germany there now is some new organisation called "Anime Copyright Allianz" (Anime Copyright Alliance -
http://www.anime-copyright-allianz.de/). This bond of anime fansites, publishers and so on has been founded for the purpose of "fighting" illegal distributions of licensed animes in Germany.
They're, as they state, not going to take legal actions against anyone, but they do their best to have any kind of illegal copy removed from streaming websites, download sources and so on as good as they can. They also offer the possibility for everyone to send in illegal anime sources so they can work to shut them down or something like that.
Soo, now my thoughts on it:
Know an important thing: I am NOT against copyright. I really, really think that whoever creates something also deserves to be paid for the hours and hours of work he has done and to be credited in an appropriate way.
But here are my doubts now:
First off...there are anime distributors in it. Well, of course, seems logical. But well, call me paranoid or anything, but whenever there's a company involved that earns its money with a certain topic, I immediatly feel as if...well...money is the only thing they care about anyway. So, do the interests of fans even matter to them anymore? In most cases, with most companies, I'd say "No", because all they do is being "nice enough" so their fans don't run away, so, only treating them "a little bit like shit".
I'm NOT saying that the ACA does this, but I'm just a little afraid it'll turn out that way.
But that's only one point and it's the smallest one. Here are the other two:
1. Dojinshis
Doujinshis, those are fan-created and normally fan-published mangas. In several cases they feature original stories, but very often, especially in Japan, they're "fanfiction" works of bigger, more or less well-known series. So, from a copyright point of view they're illegal, because the fans don't have the right to create and then sell them (normally for very cheap prices). But as far as my knowledge goes most Japanese companies tolerate this kind of behaviour. After all it is some kind of advertisment for their products and it doesn't steal away any sales of the original works.
The German doujinshi community is small...compared to the Asian one nearly non-existant I'd say. I think that REALLY is a pity. I'd love to read more of 'em, but as I cannot read Japanese, well, I'm very limited in choices. Maybe we don't have enough anime fans, maybe not enough artists or maybe they're just too afraid to publish such stuff and end up being sued by the German license-owners in the end.
So, what about the ACA? Will fans have to be afraid now? Afraid that their "fanwork", which they do from their hearts because they love the series they know and want to work with it, will be seen as serious copyright infringement and that they end up, well, not sued then, but blocked, removed and despised for doing something that, in my opinion, deserves some damn straight respect and honour?
As I said, the doujinshi community here is much smaller and it would be awful if this will mean the ultimate death of it...we shall see, how the ACA will handle things and what the influence will be.
2. The general way animes will develop now.
We have German dubs (German voice actors) for anime series. Back then many dubs were very crappy done or plainly translated wrong. Even subtitles by fansubs were often much better than the "official" subtitles. Today, dubs have become better. But still, I so much prefer the Japanese voices and reading subtitles.
And how will go things now?
You know the series Ranma 1/2? Back then I loved the series (especially female Ranma *purrs*). I SO wanted to have the series. And then the time had come, there was a DVD box release! BUT...it only had German dub. No Japanese voices, no subtitles, no...anything else.
I did not buy it. I was feeling bad, I hated it. It was so sad. I haven't found any fansub of it anymore, as most "reputable" fansub studios stop spreading their work once it is licensed in their country.
And there are other things. Changing translations on purpose, to make them feel "more native" to the audience, changing characters age due to "moral guidelines", censoring swearwords and insults. We want something but we don't get it, because it sells better "their way".
We have fansubs, because they're mostly "true to the original", they often have great quality and you know the people behind it really love what they do as they do it for free and with all their heart.
Asides fansubs, what else? Anime music videos. Will they die now? Because they contain licensed scenes from animes? Most likely not, as the ACA states they only search for "full episodes and movies", but who know how it'll develop and what other people will do with similar, maybe more "extremist" projects?
So, what to say in conclusion? I don't "hate" the ACA, they're new, I don't know them. Maybe they're genuine fans who want to support the fandom. Maybe they're commercial assholes only caring about money and giving a fuck about fans once they squeezed out all of their money. Who knows. Anime DVDs are expensive here. Will they get cheaper now, as they have a new "force" on their side that'll help get rid of pirated copies? I HIGHLY doubt that. Will the quality of dubs increase? I doubt so.
Maybe nothing will change, maybe things will get worse. We don't know.
I do NOT want to insult the ACA here. If they do a good job and help the fandom improve, yeah, that's great then. But if they become something like other German copyright and licence fee organisations (GEMA, GEZ), oh well, what the fuck, that'll be baaad.
I'll keep an open eye on them and see how stuff develops. I hope for the best. But I still fear that in the end we, the fans and customers, will end up beaten up and made fun of by big companies.
So, yeah, those are my thoughts. ACA people: if you do a great job, you've got all of my best wishes. Please, always remember: You're still anime fans, aren't you? Don't betray us. Don't become the monster we fans despite and try to fight (in vain) for so long already.
Greetings, have a nice day,
RealZero